“O, PIONEERS!”
I want to conclude this Women’s Herstory Month with a glimpse into the pioneering work of the great Caroline Leach. Many universities and other groups studied Oakhurst Presbyterian Church when Caroline and I were pastors there. They came to learn from Oakhurst how to do interracial and community ministry from a church that had almost died in the early 1980’s, after losing 90% of its membership over 15 years. One of the groups who studied us was Dr. Charles Foster, faculty at Candler School of Theology at Emory University. He and his graduate student Ted Brelsford, studied us for two years, and they published a book on their findings called “We Are Church Together: Cultural Diversity in Congregational Life.” In that book, they described Caroline this way as they studied the church:
“Caroline, Nibs’s spouse and Oakhurst’s associate pastor, greets us also. Caroline is striking and friendly in this setting. For the most part, I have seen and heard of Caroline before primarily in her capacity as minister of outreach: challenging the status quo at school board meetings; taking commissioners to task for feeble and discriminating housing policies; advocating for the community health center, drug addicted children, illiterate adults, low income parents. This morning she is not carrying those burdens. She seems excited and buoyant. She is delighted to meet my family and eager to make us feel comfortable.”
Caroline did bring that “can do” spirit to our ministry together, which started in Norfolk, Virginia in 1975. Sometimes, I would be Eyeore to her Christopher Robin, to borrow from the Winnie the Pooh stories. Perhaps she got that from her encounter with all the male systems which sought to tell her “no.” When she came to Columba Seminary in 1971, she was one of five women students there. Some of the male students would accost her on campus to read to her from the Bible, especially using the Pauline gospels which seemed to denigrate women. When she went to seminary, she was not intending to be ordained as a pastor – she was there to become a Christian educator. Yet, the strong male resistance to her presence convinced her that only by becoming an ordained pastor would she have the power and the strength to resist such pressure and to find ways to thrive as a daughter of God.
That same resistance continued as she neared graduation from seminary – the office of student support told her that they would not refer her or the two other women students to interview with churches who were seeking a pastor. Was this because they were unfit as a pastors? No, they were highly qualified pastors. Their resistance came from their gender – women were not supposed to be pastors in churches. Leave that to the men, please. Through her connections, Caroline found a campus ministry position at Georgia Tech, through the gracious invitation of Woody McKay, the senior campus minister there. The number of women students at Tech was growing, and he had the wisdom to discern that he needed a woman pastor on the staff to take the lead in offering ministry to the women students.
Atlanta Presbytery was not thrilled that Caroline and other women were beginning to hear God’s call to them to become ministers. Caroline was the second woman to seek ordination in Atlanta Presbytery, and she had a hard time getting to that opportunity. Though she had grown up in Central Presbyterian Church in Chattanooga, Tennessee, and had been all over the church in terms of participation and leadership and service, the elders there decided that they could not sponsor her to be a candidate for ministry because they did not believe that God could possibly call women to be pastors. Although she was deeply hurt by this rejection by her home church, she was not to be denied. During her seminary years, she worshipped at Central Presbyterian in Atlanta. She sought help from Reverend Randy Taylor, who was the senior pastor there, and he welcomed her into candidacy for the ministry.
After jumping through many hoops and leaping (sometimes crawling) over many obstacles, she was finally approved for ordination to the ministry by Atlanta Presbytery. In June, 1973, she was ordained as a pastor, holding the ceremony at Georgia Tech. She was the 21st woman ordained as a pastor in the former Southern Presbyterian Church. If you haven’t noted already, she is the senior pastor in our family by two years.
In many ways, Caroline and a few other women helped to blow open the locked and shut doors, which sought to bar women from entering ministry. She had to come through many dangers, toils and snares in order to make it into ordained ministry as a pastor, and to help pave the way for future women who heard God calling their names. I give thanks for Caroline’s gifts to me and to so many others in this pioneering spirit and in her determined (and yet buoyant and excited) ministry.