“ALWAYS IDA B. WELLS”
To close out Black History Month, I want to revisit one of my favorite people in American history – the fantastic Ida B. Wells. I first met her in a book “Black Foremothers” by Dorothy Sterling, when I read it in 1985 to get ready to preach on Black History Month at Oakhurst. I was stunned to read about her – several things struck me. First, I thought that I knew a fair amount about Black History, but I had never heard of her, despite all her witnessing and accomplishments for justice and equity. But, she was little known in American history. Thanks to her daughter, Alfreda Duster, and to the rest of her family, especially her great-granddaughter Michelle Duster, Ida B. is much better known now. Her daughter Alfreda Duster collected Ida B.’s journals and writings and molded them into a manuscript called “Crusade for Justice,” and began to seek a publisher. It would be 1970 before she convinced John Hope Franklin to include “Crusade for Justice” in a series published by the University of Chicago.
Second, I was also stunned to learn that Ida B. Wells was born in the same county in Mississippi as all my mother’s forebears – Marshall County in northwest Mississippi. Mother was born in Byhalia in 1919, and Ida B. was born into slavery in 1862 in Holly Springs. Wells and my mother were the same type of women – short, fierce, and strong. Whereas my mother never became an official social activist like Ida B. did, she made her statements on the issues of the day. (For more on that journey, see my book “She Made a Way: Mother and Me in a Deep South World,” published in 2024). These geographical and spiritual connections to Ida B. Wells motivated me to research Wells and dedicate myself to helping to make her more widely known. Indeed, Dr. Catherine Meeks and I wrote a book on Wells and her influence in today’s world called “Passionate For Justice: Ida B. Wells as Prophet For Our Time,” published in 2019.
In studying Wells and her life and witness, I discovered one more strong connection between her and my geography. In 2016, the Equal Justice Initiative (EJI) published a study of lynchings in America, especially in the South. Right after the study came out, I got an e-mail from my long-time Helena friend David Billings (whose own memoir “Deep Denial” is powerful on these issues also). In the e-mail, David indicated that Helena and Phillips County topped the list for localities that had killed the most Black people in lynchings. The EJI study indicated that at least 230 Black people had been killed in a rampage of white violence in a three day massacre in early fall, 1919 in Elaine and Helena. I had heard about the “Elaine Race Riot” as I grew up in Philips County, but I had accepted the narrative that Black folk had started it, and that the white violence in response had killed only a few Black men. It was done to keep Black people in their place.
The reality is much different, as several studies have shown. The “Elaine Massacre,” - as it came to be known - began when white sheriff’s deputies tried to stop a meeting of Black tenant farmers, who were seeking to organize to protect their cotton prices. Everyone was armed, and though historians dispute over who fired first, my own sense is that the deputies fired first. The wounding and killing of people on both sides ignited a white firestorm of violence. For three days, armed white mobs roamed throughout Phillips County, killing whatever Black people they could find. The US Army was called in to quell the massacre, but they ended up killing more Black people.
When the racist bloodlust calmed down, at least 237 Black people had been murdered, one of the worst mass killings in American history – in my home county. Investigations began, and to no one’s surprise, the Black people were blamed for the white violence. Over 120 Black people were charged and convicted in the investigation, and twelve of them were sentenced to death. Two modern books stand out as sources on this – “Blood in Their Eyes” by Grif Stockley and “On the Laps of Gods” by Robert Whitaker.” I also discovered an article in the Arkansas Historical Quarterly "The Underlying Causes of the Elaine Riot of 1919," by Dr. J. W. Butts and Dorothy James, published in the Spring issue, 1961. It was written by the parent of a high school classmate of mine. It was an effort to “whitewash” the violence of the Elaine Massacre, and it also sought to discredit a study done by Ida B. Wells on the Massacre.
Because of the horrific nature of the massacre, Wells decided to come back South from her exile (returning after almost 30 years of exile after her newspaper offices had been burned in Memphis in 1893). She interviewed victims of the Massacre and published a foundational study entitled “The Arkansas Race Riot.” Yet, she also did much more, and next week we’ll look at her study and her witness. Her courage and her investigative powers provide us with a commodity that seems to be in such short supply these days: hope. As the Reverend Jesse Jackson put it so well: “Keep Hope Alive!”